On October 9, the Yankees’ postseason was on the line. The Kansas City Royals had taken Game 2 in the Bronx to even the ALDS, and a win in Game 3 would push New York to the edge of another playoff exit. Then, a disputed call added to the tension. Aaron Judge was incorrectly called out on a check swing to end the seventh inning in a tie game, sparking visible frustration from Yankees players and coaches. Despite the chaos, Judge remained calm, unclipping his shin guard and walking back to the dugout.
Moments later, Giancarlo Stanton launched a go-ahead homer in the eighth inning, a decisive blow that ultimately secured the game and set the Yankees on a path to clinch the series. They would go on to defeat the Cleveland Guardians in the ALCS and reach the World Series for the first time since 2009.
He moves to the next pitch or moment better than anyone,” Yankees hitting coach James Rowson explained. “He’s able to stay calm, and that energy flows to everyone else. You might lose focus in those moments, but his ability to stay centered brings everyone back.”
This steadiness is Judge’s “second superpower,” alongside his generational swing. Throughout the season, he remained composed, whether in a hitting slump or when at the top of his game, embodying the resilience and consistency that have become a cornerstone of his leadership. For his teammates, Judge’s level-headed approach is a source of stability and motivation.
The Yankees captain not only inspires with his bat but also with his grounded presence in the clubhouse. Shortstop Anthony Volpe remarked on Judge’s work ethic and genuine treatment of others, calling it something to aspire to. Oswaldo Cabrera noted how Judge’s temperament never wavers, whether in success or frustration.
Judge credits his unshakable approach to a blend of learned habits and influences from former teammates. When he first joined the big leagues, he admired the consistency of veteran players like Mark Teixeira, whose regimented preparation was as much an inspiration as his on-field skills.
It’s been a journey marked by both acclaim and relentless demands on Judge’s time and attention. He counters this pressure with a no-nonsense demeanor, sticking to a playbook that keeps him focused on his inner circle and the ultimate goal — winning. Rarely outspoken in media, Judge keeps the focus on his performance and team goals, much like Derek Jeter before him, adding to his respect within the Yankees organization.
Now, as the Yankees approach the World Series, they’re just four victories away from achieving a long-awaited title. Judge’s offensive numbers in the postseason have dipped, but his influence remains critical. His mere presence, even in a slump, keeps the team balanced, with stars like Juan Soto, Gleyber Torres, and Giancarlo Stanton stepping up.
The Yankees’ roster depth has been pivotal to reaching this point, yet Judge’s influence extends far beyond his own stat line. Of course, his power at the plate would be a valuable asset in defeating the Dodgers. But Judge’s focus is on the team’s triumph, not personal numbers. Winning the championship has been his goal since signing his landmark contract in 2022, and he’s embraced the weight of being Yankees captain.
With the World Series now within reach, Judge stands on the edge of fulfilling a long-held dream — to lift a championship trophy. He knows that for the Yankees, and for his legacy, ultimate success is measured by what happens in October. Without a title, Judge’s legacy would remain unfinished. Now, he has the chance to change that.
